The demise of the doctrine of innocent purchaser?: Analysis of the Supreme Court decision in Tarabana vis a vis the decision in Dina Management.

The demise of the doctrine of innocent purchaser?: Analysis of the Supreme Court decision in Tarabana vis-à-vis the decision in Dina Management.

Introduction
It is not in dispute that the doctrine of innocent purchaser for value with regards to land acquisition is one of the most tenets of principles that guide the acquisition, ownership, use and utilization of land in Kenya. The doctrine has been in application in the country for a long period of time and courts have always been vigilant to adopt and apply its provisions and attendant implications in dispute resolution. This doctrine, as envisaged in its worldwide and rich application, provides for the protection of the innocent purchaser of land. However, in its recent decisions, viz, in Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others (2023) eKLR and more recently in Tarabana Company Limited v Sehmi & 7 others (Civil Appeal (Application) 463 of 2019) [2023] KECA 1346 (KLR) (10 November 2023) the Supreme Court has more or less muddied the waters with regards to the application of the principle further complicating this remedy and effectively denying the innocent purchaser for value any recourse with regards to land purchased without notice of any irregularity, fraud/ and or illegalities.

Tarabana Company Limited v Sehmi & 7 others (Civil Appeal (Application) 463 of 2019) [2023] KECA 1346 (KLR) (10 November 2023) (Ruling)

In Tarabana Company Limited v Sehmi & 7 others (Civil Appeal (Application) 463 of 2019) [2023] KECA 1346 (KLR) (10 November 2023) (Ruling), the Supreme Court was presented with an important and pertinent opportunity to clarify the import of its decision in Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others (2023) eKLR that effectively removed any protection to an innocent purchaser for value with regards to public land. The Appellants were the registered proprietors of L.R. No. 209/2759/9 (I.R. 6477), situated in the Ngara area of Nairobi (hereinafter referred to as the “suit property”). They had acquired the property in 1968 from Elizabeth Ann Maria Estreta Rodrigues for a consideration of Kshs. 25,000/- and were duly registered as tenants in common. The tenure of the property was a leasehold for a term of fifty-nine (59) years commencing on 1st October 1942 and was scheduled to expire or for extension on the 1st October 2001. However, in October 2014, they were forcibly evicted from the property by the 1st and 2nd respondents who laid claim on the property under a separate title bearing a new I.R. number, L.R. No. 209/2759/9 (I.R 12263).

The main issue before the court, as was the case in the Dina Management Case, was whether the Appellants could avail themselves of the protection enshrined in the principle of innocent purchaser for value with respect to the purchase of public land without notice of any illegality or irregularity in relation to its attendant acquisition. According to the Supreme Court, the innocent purchaser for value ought to prove the existence of three inter-related aspects: innocence, purchaser for value and also legal estate. On the first part, the court asserted that the innocent purchaser for value ought to prove that he was not involved in any appurtenant illegalities and/or fraud related to the acquisition of the property. As such, it also needs to be demonstrated that he or she had conducted due diligence to assert the title’s propriety. With respect to the aspect for the purchaser for value, it had to be demonstrated that the purchaser had actually paid the full amount for the purchase of the property. It also has to be proven that the property in question was capable of being acquired, viz the requirement of legal estate.

However, with regards to the first aspect, which is the main aspect, the court seems to place a varied form of expectation on the purchaser with regard to the due diligence that is required. According to the court, in so far as there is evidence of illegality, even if the same was not availed before the purchaser, then the purchaser cannot be said to have acquired the property innocently. The court stated as follows:
“…buys property in good faith without notice of any defect or claims against the title. So that if the title in question is illegal or obtained through unlawful means, the purchaser cannot claim protection even if he was not aware of the illegality.”

The court also referred to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Torino Enterprises Limited vs. Attorney General (Petition 5 (E006) of 2022) [2023] KESC 79 (KLR) where the Court held that an innocent purchaser for value denotes a purchaser who exercised due diligence, which would include, but is not limited to, inspecting the suit property. It explained further as follows;
‘What about the argument to the effect that the appellant was an innocent purchaser for value without notice? It is obvious by now that such argument cannot hold in view of our pronouncements regarding the transactions between Renton and the appellant. … there is evidence on record in the form of correspondence and minutes, confirming that DoD had been granted access by the defunct municipal council and had taken possession of, and erected public infrastructure upon the suit property before the purported purchase…. Further, it is on record that the Ministry of Lands and Settlement was monitoring excision activities by NCC to ensure that the portion occupied by DoD was not affected…. Therefore, if the appellant was a diligent purchaser, it ought to have at least known of this fact. An innocent purchaser for value would also denote one was aware of what they were purchasing by inspecting the suit premises. This takes us to the question of whether the appellant had visited the suit premises and if so, what was its impression of the military installations on the suit premises? The fact that the suit land was occupied must have sounded a warning of “buyer be aware” to the appellant. We therefore find that it was not an innocent purchaser for value entitled to orders for restoration or compensation (Emphasis Ours).

According to the Supreme Court, the purchaser in the Torino Enterprises Limited (Supra) could not have undertaken due diligence in a proper manner to confirm the propriety of the previous ownership since after visiting the suit property, he ought to have seen military installations which would have led them to question the title’s propriety.

The court thereby went ahead to assert that the purchaser in the current case was not an innocent purchaser for value since the property had been previously acquired illegally. The court asserted that since equity follows the law, the purchaser could not be heard to seek the protection of equity through the doctrine of innocent purchaser for value.

In context, the court in Tarabana Company Limited v Sehmi & 7 others (Civil Appeal (Application) 463 of 2019) [2023] KECA 1346 (KLR) (10 November 2023) (Ruling) follows the decision Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others (2023) eKLR where the scope and context and the rights attendant to the innocent purchaser were cancelled. The court failed to shed light and clarify what is meant by the concept of the innocent purchaser for value with respect to the purchase of public land without any notice of or knowledge of illegality.

By application of the decision in Torino Enterprises Limited where the court asserted that by visiting the site the purchaser ought to have seen the military installations and asked questions regarding the propriety of the title of the previous owner of land. However, in real circumstances, it is not often the case that when the intended purchasers conduct due diligence and also visit the land they intend to buy they will chance upon glaring facts appurtenant to fraud in the land’s acquisition as was the case in Torino Enterprises Limited.

The decision in the current case is bad law as it magnifies and nearly leads to the demise of the concept of due diligence. To what extent is the prospective buyer required to conduct due diligence before purchasing property? Are there additional scopes of due diligence that ought to be complied with by intended buyers of property in this regard and what do the same entail? What is the remedy available then to the innocent purchaser of property when the court cancels title on account of alleged impropriety by the property’s previous owner? There are the questions and aspects that recommend themselves for resolution in future litigation since the current position by the Supreme Court as held in Tarabana Company Limited v Sehmi & 7 others (Civil Appeal (Application) 463 of 2019) [2023] KECA 1346 (KLR) (10 November 2023) more or else renders the concept of due diligence moot and irrelevant.

104 Responses

  1. I’ve been trying a few different platforms lately and this one really stands out. The interface is smooth and the payouts are surprisingly fast. Definitely worth a try for anyone looking for a reliable spot. ww55vip

  2. Дом Rick Owens воспринимается как авангардный бренд, появившийся более тридцати лет назад с чёткой протестной философией и узнаваемым подходом на границе тёмного гламура и рок-н-ролла.
    Рик Оуэнс известен скульптурными драпировками, нестандартными формами и выбором текстурированных материалов наряду с минималистичным кроем и глубокими оттенками.
    rick-owens-moscow.ru
    Бренд соединяет премиальность и бунтарство, предлагая гардероб для людей выбирает самовыражение и не боится выглядеть провокационно.
    Сегодня эта марка является уже не только мода, но и целое эстетическое высказывание, охватывающее предметы интерьера, экстравагантную обувь и философию осознанного бунтарства.

  3. I’ve been trying a few different spots lately and this one really stands out. The interface is smooth and the payouts are quick. Definitely check out 98zcom if you want a reliable experience.

  4. Omo, 24jbetlogin is giving me serious good vibes. Fast betting and quick withdrawals keep my heart racing in a good way. The platform never disappoints when I want to catch the weekend matches. No wahala here. 24jbetlogin

  5. Living in Chile makes finding a trustworthy casino tricky but this one completely nails it. The payment methods are perfectly set up for us locals and the game selection keeps me entertained for hours. I always recommend it to anyone looking for a genuine experience. betwaycasinochile

  6. Следите за самыми важными событиями игровой индустрии вместе с нашим разделом новостей. Здесь мы разбираем громкие анонсы, неожиданные заявления разработчиков, даты выхода игр, патчи, дополнения и события киберспорта. Получайте актуальную информацию о онлайн казино для ПК, консолей и мобильных устройств: от крупных блокбастеров до необычных инди-игр. В разделе выходят публикации о том, что действительно обсуждают игроки, какие новинки готовятся к релизу и какие изменения уже появились в любимых играх.

  7. Stumbled across 95vn earlier. They’ve got some interesting niche games. Takes a bit to get used to the interface, but overall, alright. If you’re bored of the usual, give them a bash. 95vn

  8. I was searching for a betting platform that actually respects its users and I am so glad I gave this one a chance. The odds are genuinely competitive and the interface is so intuitive that even my older relatives figured it out within minutes. Withdrawals hit my account almost instantly and the weekend promotions are always worth grabbing. It has completely replaced my old routine. Log in and start playing at bdl222

  9. Downloading this app was super easy and it runs perfectly on my phone. I love the variety of sports markets and the live streaming feature makes watching matches even more exciting. Safe and reliable for sure. dbbetapp

  10. I have been searching for a reliable spot to play my favorite casino games and finally found a place that actually delivers on its promises. The game selection is massive and payouts arrive quickly without unnecessary delays. Great customer support team that stays responsive around the clock. Highly recommend giving it a try if you want a smooth gaming experience. vnpkwn

  11. Alright mates, just wanna say I’ve been kickin’ around on kk99game lately and it’s not bad! Got some decent slots and the site runs smooth as butter. Give it a burl, yeah? kk99game

  12. Vay88 – I’ve spent some time on it. Solid enough, nothing offensively bad. They’ve got a decent number of games, and the site is easy enough to navigate. A bit generic, but works a charm and I keep coming back! Give vay88 a go.

  13. Appvay88… It’s got an app! Which is nice. Easier than messing around on a browser if you are on the go. Worth downloading if you wanna dabble on your phone. Check out the App: appvay88.

  14. Okay, so I tried fb7777slot. If you’re dead set on playing slots, it’s a place to do it, I suppose. Nothing special, but hey, slots are slots, right? Don’t expect fireworks but it’s passable. Hit up fb7777slot if slots are your thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *