Virtual Oaths & E-Sworn Truths: Can an Affidavit Be Taken Without Physical Presence?

Virtual Oaths & E-Sworn Truths: Can an Affidavit Be Taken Without Physical Presence?

COVID-19 changed the world in more ways than one, and some of the changes it wrought on our day-to-day activities lasted beyond the covid years. Due to the lockdown and limitation of physical interactions, we were all forced to find new ways to do old things. The relatively standpat field of litigation was not exempt from these changes. Since the advent of covid, alternative processes had to be adopted and have persisted like virtual court sessions, electronic signatures on court documents, virtual meetings with clients, etc. Technology is now inextricably embedded in litigation.

The Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act prescribe the requirements for the taking of an affidavit and that the Commissioner of Oaths will state truly the place and date when an oath or affidavit is taken before them. This begs the question, does this have to be done in the physical presence of the Commissioner of Oaths or is it possible to satisfy the mandatory requirements of the Act virtually?

Justice Mwangi Njoroge was faced with this very question seated at the Malindi Environment and Land Court in the matter of Andrea Moretti and Elena Dardanelli & 5 others vs Jokafa Limited and Pasquale Tirito & 2 others.

The Plaintiffs in this matter entered into long-term lease agreements with the Defendants (being the company and the directors of the company) in respect of villas in Kilifi. One of the terms of the lease agreements was that any dispute arising therefrom would be referred to arbitration. The 1st and 2nd Defendants, on the 23rd of August 2024, thus made an application that there be a stay of proceedings and for the matter to be referred to arbitration.

The Plaintiffs/Respondents opted to not only argue the application on its substance, but also deployed considerable effort in attacking it on its form. The Respondents’ arguments proceeded on two fronts; that the deponent lacked authority from the company to swear it and that any attempt to file the authority after the application would be a nullity; and that it misleads the court by stating that it was sworn in Kenya while the deponent was not in Kenya at the date of its swearing.

The second issue made for a rather alluring deliberation by the court. It’s important to note from the outset that the Defendants/Applicants admitted that the deponent was not in Kenya at the time of swearing of the affidavit. Thus, the issue before the Court was that he never physically appeared before the commissioner for oaths during the taking of the affidavit.

Section 5 of the Oaths and Statutory Declarations Act provides that:

“Every Commissioner for oaths before whom any oath or affidavit is taken or made under this Act shall state truly in the jurat or attestation at what place and on what date the oath or affidavit is taken or made.”

The court held that the presence of the deponent before the Commissioner for Oaths taking the affidavit is important because the contents of an affidavit are statements under oath which may lead to offence of perjury if care is not taken. Thus, it is important that the deponent is present and is satisfied that the contents are correct and the commissioner is also satisfied that the deponent understands what he is swearing.

The dangers of not doing so are two-fold. If a deponent ever disputes the veracity of statements in affidavits filed in legal proceedings, there may be a lot of back-pedaling occasioning the undesired bloating of the court’s backlog of cases. The commissioner affixing his stamp in the absence of a deponent, while stating at the place and on what date the affidavit is taken, would be in effect uttering a falsehood.

To militate against this, the Applicant submitted that the deponent met the commissioner virtually and affixed his electronic signature as well. This was the novel argument that piqued the interest of the judge.

In considering this, the court first restated the established position that submissions are not evidence. Affidavits are evidence while submissions are simply statements from the bar. Thus, the deponent would have had to state in their affidavit that they met the commissioner virtually and not leave it to counsel to state the same in their submissions.

Secondly, the Court noted that since COVID-19 matters have certainly changed significantly to the extent that even court proceedings occur virtually. Thus, it would not be improper for a virtual meeting to satisfy the requirements of section 5 above.
However, this must also abide by the law of evidence, specifically section 106B of the Evidence Act that would require the commissioner or the deponent to present a certificate to prove the online activity. The certificate(s) would necessarily speak to the process followed in procuring the affidavit and in procuring the attendance of the deponent for the taking of the affidavit before the commissioner. The absence of the above certificate(s) would be fatal and the affidavit must be struck out.

Despite the acknowledged validity of virtual meetings and the propriety of electronic signatures, the Application was struck out with costs because the Applicants had not presented the certificate to prove that this supposed virtual meeting occurred.

The Court has now established that a Commissioner for Oaths can take an affidavit virtually while the deponent is in a different location physically. However, the process of procuring the affidavit, electronic signature and the virtual presence of the deponent ought to be confirmed with a certificate as per section 106B of the Evidence Act.

This case serves as a timely reminder to legal practitioners, the use of technology in litigation is not just about convenience, it must also comply with the letter of the law. Advocates and Commissioners must exercise diligence, precision, and foresight in adapting traditional legal formalities to the realities of the digital age.

105 Responses

  1. Обмен USDT на наличные является современный и безопасный инструмент использовать заработанные криптовалюту по низкими комиссиями и высоким сервисом.
    Этот способ обеспечивает оперативное зачисление суммы и высокую безопасность обмена благодаря проверенным обменникам и ясным условиям.
    cashterms.pro
    Кроме того, обмен USDT на наличные предлагается в удобное момент и при этом включает различные способы и вместе с тем квалифицированную сопровождение на любом этапе операции.

  2. SEO-продвижение представляет собой проверенным методом для естественного роста представленности сайта в Google и Яндекса.
    Поисковая оптимизация обеспечивает привлекать качественную пользователей через поисковых систем и формировать прочные отношения с аудиторией.
    https://seo-favorite.ru/
    Также SEO позволяет сделать ресурс по-настоящему полезным для посетителей и формирует хорошую базу для уверенного роста бизнеса.

  3. Дом Rick Owens является независимый дом моды, появившийся в середине 1990-х с чёткой антибуржуазной установкой и узнаваемым почерком на стыке тёмного гламура и бунтарства.
    Основатель приобрёл известность объёмными драпировками, нестандартными пропорциями и применением плотной кожи в сочетании с минимализмом и глубокими оттенками.
    Рик Оэунс
    Марка балансирует роскошь и нонконформизм, предлагая вещи для ценит индивидуальность и готов выглядеть эпатажно.
    В наши дни этот бренд представляет собой не просто гардероб, а также узнаваемое мировоззрение, охватывающее мебель, обувь и подход личного бунтарства.

  4. I have been playing on this platform for a few months now and the consistency is impressive. Every bonus round triggers fairly and the customer team responds within minutes. It is exactly what a laid back player needs to unwind after work. jili11app

  5. I’ve been trying a few different sites lately, but the experience here is surprisingly smooth. The payouts are fast and the interface is very user-friendly. Highly recommend r888bet for anyone looking for a reliable spot.

  6. Alright, a bit of the high life with taibetvip. If you’re lookin’ for something a little more upscale, might be worth checking out. See if you can snag that VIP treatment. Check out the VIP life here: taibetvip

  7. Been playing online for years and this platform stands out for its honest gameplay and quick cashouts. I appreciate how they keep the interface clean without unnecessary pop ups. My friends and I started using it together and everyone loves the consistent service. bd1111bet33

  8. pkrs789 has a great community feel. The games are fair and the rewards are legit. I’ve spent a few hours here this week and I’m really enjoying the vibe.

  9. This platform really understands what regular players need from a betting site. The live dealer options are top notch and the chat function works perfectly. I have never dealt with any payment delays here and the security measures give me peace of mind while playing. idpphoki

  10. My friends keep raving about this platform and now I get the hype. The interface is clean and the promotions actually match the fine print. It has become my go to spot for weekend entertainment. bio368me

  11. Downloaded the 23betapp recently. Quick and easy to use, which is a big plus. Doesn’t have all the bells and whistles, but if you just want to place a quick bet, it’s perfect. Find it at 23betapp

  12. I have tried quite a few platforms but this one stands out for its incredible bonus structure. The wagering requirements are fair and the free spins trigger more often than I expected. Staff members are always polite and ready to guide you through the games. It is refreshing to find a casino that puts player satisfaction first. betvipcasinobono

  13. I have been exploring different online casinos lately and I really love how smooth the gaming experience feels here. The slot library is fantastic and the mobile app runs like a dream. Customer support is also super quick to help with any questions. If you are looking for a reliable place to spin and win big give this one a try. gg8slot

  14. I downloaded your app and I have to say the interface is super clean and intuitive. I really enjoy the daily promotions because they keep the gameplay fresh and rewarding. Payments are handled quickly and I never felt frustrated while navigating different sections. You have built something really special here and I am happy to be part of this community. bronabetapp

  15. I really enjoy how authentic the slot collection feels here. Every game runs perfectly and the payout rates seem very fair compared to other sites I have tried. Withdrawals hit my account within a day and the support staff is always friendly when I need help. Highly recommend this spot to friends. abcrummy

  16. Downloaded the app and it runs so smoothly on my phone. The graphics are top notch and I never experienced any lag during my sessions. Deposits reflect instantly and I appreciate the multiple payment options available. It feels like a premium gaming hub that really cares about its community. jdbkkapp

  17. Hey guys! Checked out Geelyslots the other day and, honestly, it was a decent experience. Lots of slots to choose from and the signup process was quick. Could use a bit more live dealer games though. Check it out here: geelyslots

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *